The exhibition The Art of Disagreeing Badly: Religious Dispute in Early Modern Europe is now available on an interactive website.
The sixteenth and seventeenth centuries were an age of confessional polemic. After the beginning of the Reformation in 1517, church history presented a challenge to each confession in its own right. Protestants aimed to explain, through examples from history, why error had come into the Church after apostolic times and after centuries of decadence the Reformation had become necessary. Catholics argued, on the other hand, that the Church had always remained the same. Protestants also doubted specific key events in church history. They asserted, for example, that St Peter had never been in Rome, so that the Petrine tradition, on which the papacy based its own primacy, was invalid. Catholics, of course, never doubted Peter’s stay in Rome. Many other such polemical arguments were thrown back and forth, making church history a hot battleground of the confessionnal struggle. A large number of the books exhibited are from the collection of Tobie Matthew, Archbishop of York (1546-1628).
The physical exhibition was curated by Dr Stefan Bauer and Bethany Hume, from the University of York, and was on display at the Old Palace, York Minster from 15 November – 15 December 2016. The exhibition showcasee the collections of the York Minster library, examining the role of religious polemic in the early modern period.